• FREE SHIPPING ON SELECT ITEMS • NEW INVENTORY ADDED DAILY

Search Cart

Cat Supplies

463 products

463 products

  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Clear all
Clear all

  • NEW Weruva Mideast Feast Grilled Tilapia in Gravy Cat Food (3oz)

    $2.19 USD
    $2.19 USD
    NEW Weruva Mideast Feast Grilled Tilapia in Gravy Cat Food (3oz)

  • NEW Wellness Complete Health Adult Turkey Dinner Pate Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

    $3.29 USD
    $3.29 USD
    NEW Wellness Complete Health Adult Turkey Dinner Pate Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

  • NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Salmon Pate Entree Wet Cat Cans

    From $1.99 USD
    From $1.99 USD
    NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Salmon Pate Entree Wet Cat Cans

  • NEW Fancy Feast Oceanfish & Tuna Pate Wet Cat Food (3oz)

    $1.39 USD
    $1.39 USD
    NEW Fancy Feast Oceanfish & Tuna Pate Wet Cat Food (3oz)

  • NEW Solid Gold Adult Grain Free Winged Tiger Quail and Pumpkin Cat Food (3lb)

    $23.99 USD
    $23.99 USD
    NEW Solid Gold Adult Grain Free Winged Tiger Quail and Pumpkin Cat Food (3lb)

  • NEW Fancy Feast Tuna (3oz)

    $1.39 USD
    $1.39 USD
    NEW Fancy Feast Tuna (3oz)

  • NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Kitten Chicken Pate Entree Wet Cat Cans (3oz)

    $1.99 USD
    $1.99 USD
    NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Kitten Chicken Pate Entree Wet Cat Cans (3oz)

  • NEW Fancy Feast Appetizers Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food (1.1oz)

    $1.49 USD
    $1.49 USD
    NEW Fancy Feast Appetizers Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food (1.1oz)

  • NEW Sheba Perfect Portions Premium Pate Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food (2.65oz)

    $1.69 USD
    $1.69 USD
    NEW Sheba Perfect Portions Premium Pate Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food (2.65oz)

  • NEW Tikicat Adult Born Carnivore Chicken, Herring and Salmon Dry Kibble (2.8lb)

    $29.99 USD
    $29.99 USD
    NEW Tikicat Adult Born Carnivore Chicken, Herring and Salmon Dry Kibble (2.8lb)

  • NEW Wellness Core Adult Signature Select Shredded Chicken and Beef Entree Wet Cat Food (2.8oz)

    From $2.69 USD
    From $2.69 USD
    NEW Wellness Core Adult Signature Select Shredded Chicken and Beef Entree Wet Cat Food (2.8oz)

  • NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult 7+ Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe (7lb)

    $44.99 USD
    $44.99 USD
    NEW Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult 7+ Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe (7lb)

  • NEW Instinct Original Kitten Grain Free Chicken Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

    $3.39 USD
    $3.39 USD
    NEW Instinct Original Kitten Grain Free Chicken Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

  • NEW Evanger's All Life Stages Classic Beef It Up Dinner Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

    $1.89 USD
    $1.89 USD
    NEW Evanger's All Life Stages Classic Beef It Up Dinner Wet Cat Food (5.5oz)

  • NEW Wellness Core Adult Signature Select Shredded Chicken and Turkey Entree Wet Cat Food (2.8oz)

    From $2.69 USD
    From $2.69 USD
    NEW Wellness Core Adult Signature Select Shredded Chicken and Turkey Entree Wet Cat Food (2.8oz)

  • NEW Tikicat Adult After Dark Chicken, Chicken Liver and Quail Soft Pate (3oz)

    $2.59 USD
    $2.59 USD
    NEW Tikicat Adult After Dark Chicken, Chicken Liver and Quail Soft Pate (3oz)

Quick links

Contact

Email: cs@newplusused.com

Showroom: 505 Blue Ball Road Suite 140-D Elkton, MD 21921

In-Store Hours
Monday-Friday: 10 AM- 4 PM EST, Saturday-Sunday by Appt

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • USDC
  • Visa
© 2026. NewPlusUsed.com. All rights reserved.
Back to top
WhatsApp
Snapchat
WeChat
Viber
Messenger